The COVID-19 pandemic has significantly transformed the commercial real estate market. The rise in remote work has led to record-high office vacancy rates across the United States, especially in downtown areas.
The Mortgage Bankers Association reports that nearly $2 trillion of the $4.7 trillion in commercial real estate loans nationwide will mature over the next three years. The office sector is particularly concerning due to the sharp decline in demand for office space since the pandemic.
This situation has sparked interest in converting underused office spaces into residential properties, a practice known as adaptive reuse. Although not a new concept, office-to-residential conversions have gained traction due to increased vacancies. Cities like New York, Los Angeles, and Cleveland have been successfully implementing this strategy for decades:
-
New York City: The Lower Manhattan Revitalization Plan, introduced in the early 1990s, implemented property tax incentives to encourage office conversions. This initiative led to the transformation of numerous office buildings into residential units, playing a crucial role in revitalizing the area.
-
Los Angeles: The Los Angeles Adaptive Reuse Program, launched in 1999, has been instrumental in converting millions of square feet of office space into residential units, setting a precedent for other cities.
-
Cleveland: A pioneer in adaptive reuse since the 1970s, Cleveland has successfully created thousands of apartments from former office buildings. The city’s older buildings, with their smaller floor plates, are particularly well-suited for residential conversions.
These past efforts highlight the potential of office-to-residential conversions to breathe new life into urban areas while addressing housing needs. By drawing on these experiences, cities can craft effective policies and strategies to promote this trend and navigate the associated challenges.
Experts caution that these conversions alone won't fully address the housing crisis, but they can contribute to revitalizing urban centers by promoting a diverse mix of land uses and supporting a 24/7 economy.
Despite their potential, these conversions face significant hurdles, including building design limitations, zoning restrictions, and high conversion costs. Financial viability remains a critical concern, with many projects requiring high residential rents to offset the loss of office income. To make these conversions financially feasible, municipal governments may need to offer incentives, such as tax abatements or relaxed zoning regulations.
The Biden-Harris administration recently released a guidebook outlining federal programs aimed at reducing conversion costs and accelerating the process. These include grants, low-interest loans, and tax incentives. While the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) and the U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT) have expanded funding opportunities, some office property owners have raised concerns about the feasibility of these programs due to lengthy approval processes and restrictive location requirements.
Early data suggests that conversion projects completed so far have yielded a relatively small number of housing units compared to the nationwide need according to a report released by Center for American Progress. Since 2016, nearly 20,000 housing units have been created through office-to-residential conversions, but these conversions account for only about 1 percent of new multifamily projects. Moreover, even with 151,000 units currently in the pipeline, projections suggest these conversions alone are unlikely to significantly alleviate the housing shortage, particularly in downtown areas where high residential rents are often necessary to make projects financially viable.
As more cities explore office-to-residential conversions, it is evident that while this trend is not a comprehensive solution, it can play a pivotal role in broader strategies to alleviate housing shortages and rejuvenate urban centers. In the upcoming series of blog posts, we will explore how specific cities are navigating this complex yet promising trend.
Related Articles:
- HUD NSPIRE Updates
- Adaptive Reuse Surges Again With 151K Upcoming Units; Hotel Conversions Overtake Offices in 2023
- How Brokers Pitch Office Listings as Potential Multifamily Conversions
- How 2023 Became a Year for Office Conversions
- Implications and Geography of Office to Housing Conversions
- One in Three Office Buildings in Major North American Cities Could Be Ripe for Multifamily Conversion